McSleepy/Shutterstock.comChristmas music is a genre unto itself that balances on the fine line between pure kitsch and genuine emotion. The best Christmas songs immediately evoke a feeling of nostalgia, warmth, but often also of melancholy and loss. This list ignores the frenzy of the moment and looks at the songs that have stood the test of time. From the "Wall of Sound" of the 1960s to the synth-pop of the 1980s and authentic Dutch popular song: this is the ultimate soundtrack for under the tree.
Cast your vote - the ranking shifts live based on the votes.
The Pogues & Kirsty MacColl - Fairytale of New York
In lists of music critics, this is consistently at the top, and deservedly so. It's a miniature opera about hope, disappointment, and the raw reality, far from sugary Christmas clichés. The piano intro grabs you immediately, and the Celtic instrumentation (tin whistle, accordion) gives it a timeless soul. The chemistry between the raw Shane MacGowan and the fierce Kirsty MacColl is magical. It's a song that acknowledges that Christmas can also be painful, and that's exactly where the comfort lies.
Mariah Carey - All I Want for Christmas Is You
The only modern track that can measure up to the old standards. It's a brilliant pastiche of the 1960s "Wall of Sound", but with the vocal power of the 1990s. The tempo is murderous, the piano bounces, and Mariah sings beautifully. It's impossible not to move to this. An explosion of happiness and energy that defines Christmas for generations.
Wham! - Last Christmas
The perfect pop song. The synthesizers, the bells, and that unforgettable bass line. George Michael sings about a broken heart, but the music sounds hopeful. The contrast between the sad lyrics and the cheerful production is key to its success. The mood of the video clip (snow, sweaters, chalets) is baked into every note. Nostalgia in its purest form.
Bing Crosby - White Christmas
Fun fact: this is the best-selling single of all time. Crosby's voice is like hot chocolate with whipped cream. The tempo is slow and dreamy, full of nostalgia for a past that may never have existed. The whistling in the middle section is iconic. This song set the standard for how a Christmas song should sound: orchestral, warm, and deeply sentimental.
Youp van 't Hek - Flappie
The most unique Christmas song in Dutch history. A tragic-comic story about a rabbit, a bike shed, and a family trauma, told with the perfect timing of a cabaret artist. The piano accompaniment is simple, allowing the lyrics to take center stage. The twist from innocence to revenge is brilliant. A song that brings a smile and a lump in the throat every year.
John Lennon & Yoko Ono - Happy Xmas (War Is Over)
A protest song disguised as a Christmas classic. Produced by Phil Spector, which is evident in the full sound. The children's choir from Harlem provides the innocent counterpart to Lennon's message. "So this is Christmas, and what have you done?" The lyrics force reflection. It's hopeful and confrontational at the same time, a timeless call for peace.
Chris Rea - Driving Home for Christmas
The ultimate road trip track for December. The rhythm is a slow "shuffle", exactly like the feeling of being stuck in traffic in the snow. The piano loops sound like windshield wipers. Rea's warm, deep voice is like a safe haven. The number isn't about the party itself, but about the journey there and the anticipation. Atmospheric and soothing.
André Hazes - Eenzame Kerst (Lonely Christmas)
The king of popular song at his best. Hazes wrote this song in prison for a lonely prisoner. The lyrics are pure popular song poetry about cold streets and an empty chair. His voice trembles with emotion and the sigh is never more palpable than here. It's the ultimate song for anyone who feels alone during the days of enforced happiness. Dutch heritage.
Band Aid - Do They Know It's Christmas?
The mother of all charity singles. The synthesizer intro is iconic and menacing. The line-up is a who's who of 1980s pop (Bono, George Michael, Boy George). The opening line of Paul Young and Bono's outburst ("Well tonight thank God it's them instead of you") are legendary. It's a time capsule of musical solidarity and urgency.
Andy Williams - It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year
If Christmas had a sound, it would be this number. The three-beat measure (a waltz) gives it a swinging, festive character. The production is rich and full of details. Williams sings with contagious enthusiasm about "marshmallows" and "caroling". It's the soundtrack of the perfect, idealized American Christmas from the 1960s.
Slade - Merry Xmas Everybody
The ultimate British glam-rock stomp. Noddy Holder screams "It's Christmaaaas!" with an energy that could wake the dead. The number is full of harmonium sounds and stomping boots. It's loud, populist, and unpolished. The lyrics sketch a realistic picture of a family party with grandma dancing and drunk uncles. Pure rock-'n'-roll nostalgia.
Darlene Love - Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)
The highlight of the legendary Christmas album by Phil Spector. This is the "Wall of Sound" at its best: a hurricane of saxophones, pianos, drums, and background vocals. Darlene Love sings with a desperation and power that cuts through bone and marrow. It's euphoric and sad at the same time, the sound of a big city Christmas full of longing.
Queen - Thank God It's Christmas
A Christmas number that doesn't sound like a typical Christmas song, but is unmistakably Queen. No bells, but a slow, stomping beat and the phenomenal, powerful singing of Freddie Mercury. The lyrics are reflective and deal with the end of a difficult year. Mercury's outbursts in the chorus give the number a grandeur rarely heard in this genre. An underrated gem.
Paul McCartney - Wonderful Christmastime
You either love it or hate it, but the synthesizer riff is immortal. McCartney recorded this entirely on his own, and you can hear it: it's playful, a little clumsy, and incredibly catchy.
The echo on the vocals and the futuristic sound effects give it a unique atmosphere. It perfectly captures the childlike excitement of a Christmas party. Uncomplicated pop from a Beatle.
Miss Montreal - Being Alone at Christmas
A modern Dutch Christmas classic. Sanne Hans wrote this song as a tribute to her deceased father. The message is raw and honest: Christmas isn't a celebration for everyone. Musically it's small and acoustic, so the focus is completely on her characteristic, somewhat hoarse voice. It's a song that offers comfort to anyone who has to miss someone during the holidays.
José Feliciano - Feliz Navidad
Simplicity is sometimes the key to success. With just six words in Spanish and thirteen in English, Feliciano created a world hit. The acoustic guitar and horns provide an irresistible Latin American swing. It's the ultimate "party Christmas song". No heavy themes or complicated arrangements, just pure, uncomplicated joy that gets every Christmas party going.
The Pretenders - 2000 Miles
One of the most beautiful guitar intros in the Christmas canon. The sparkling picking of Robbie McIntosh sounds like falling snowflakes. Chrissie Hynde sings with a rare tenderness. Although it's often seen as a romantic Christmas song, it's actually a tribute to the band's deceased guitarist. That double layer gives the number its timeless, melancholic power.
Fay Lovsky - Christmas Was a Friend of Mine
A unique Dutch contribution that sounds international. Fay Lovsky uses unusual instruments like the singing saw and theremin to create a magical, almost fairytale-like atmosphere. The number sounds both retro and futuristic. The lyrics about losing the childhood magic of Christmas ("Now he's a stranger") are painfully recognizable. A cult classic for the connoisseur.
Kelly Clarkson - Underneath the Tree
The only number from this century that can truly measure up to the old classics. It's a clear ode to the Phil Spector "Wall of Sound", with saxophones, bells, and boundless energy. Clarkson sings beautifully. It's cheerful, loud, and irresistibly catchy. An instant classic that proves that timeless Christmas music can still be made.
Frank Sinatra - Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas
The definitive version of a bittersweet classic. Sinatra adjusted the original, rather depressing lyrics (changing "Hang a shining star upon the highest bough"), making it more hopeful. His voice is like a warm fireplace. The strings are lush and romantic. The number perfectly captures the feeling of reflection at the end of the year, full of melancholy and love.
Missing an item in this list?
Log in or create a free account to add an item yourself.
Log in / create account