
The Saw franchise changed horror forever with its mix of psychological tension, brutal traps and Jigsaw's complex puzzles. What began as an intense low-budget horror film grew into one of the most recognizable and gory horror series ever. Here's the ultimate ranking of all Saw films, from masterpiece to total failure.
Cast your vote - the ranking shifts live based on the votes.
Saw (2004): The First and the Best
This low-budget masterpiece by James Wan and Leigh Whannell is pure tension from start to finish. The claustrophobic setting, intense psychological horror and legendary twist ending make it one of the best horror films ever made. Without it the franchise wouldn't exist, and it remains the most brilliant and impactful Saw film.
Saw X (2023): A Surprisingly Strong Comeback
After years of mediocre sequels, Saw X breathed new life into the franchise. It dives deep into the character of John Kramer, with a strong focus on psychology and less on excessive gore. The traps are cruel but not pointless, and Tobin Bell brings Jigsaw to life in a way we hadn't seen in years.
After years of mediocre sequels, Saw X breathed new life into the franchise.
Saw II (2005): The Great Sequel
Instead of simply repeating the first film, Saw II expanded the mythology and brought Jigsaw's psychological games to a larger scale. The house-trap scenario, the cat-and-mouse game with the police and the iconic needle-pit trap make it a rock-solid, surprising sequel.
Instant classic tbh.
Saw VI (2009): The Most Socially Critical Saw Film
This film strikes the best balance between brutal traps and a strong message, with Jigsaw targeting corruption in the health insurance industry. The story is sharper than in many other installments, and the traps feel clever and meaningful again rather than purely gory. Many fans consider it the best Saw film since the original.
Still remember seeing this for the first time, blew me away hands down.
Saw III (2006): A Gruesome but Emotional Conclusion
Originally intended as the end of a trilogy, this film gives John Kramer an emotional, tragic conclusion. The traps are bloodier than ever, and the game of the father who must overcome his rage is intense. Still, it's sometimes too long and too focused on shock value, so it doesn't quite reach the magic of parts 1 and 2.
Jigsaw (2017): A Failed Attempt at Renewal
After a seven-year break, Jigsaw tried to restart the franchise, with mixed results. It has a slick look and a few interesting moments, but the twist is predictable and it doesn't really feel like a classic Saw film.
Saw IV (2007): A Messy Transition
With Jigsaw dead, the makers had to find a new direction, and that's where this film struggles. There are a few iconic traps, but it feels forced and lacks the impact of earlier installments.
Saw V (2008): The Dullest Saw Film
Here the franchise's pitfall becomes painfully clear: too much police intrigue, too little tension. It has a few good traps, but it feels like it's mostly stalling without a compelling story. The ending tries to shock but lacks the impact of earlier twists.
Saw 3D: The Final Chapter (2010): A Messy Farewell
Originally meant to be the last film, The Final Chapter feels more like an exhausted attempt to close the franchise. The traps are extremely gory but without much meaning, and Dr. Gordon's return could have been handled much better. A tiring, failed attempt to wrap up the series.
Spiral: From the Book of Saw (2021): The Worst Saw Film Ever
Despite a fresh approach with Chris Rock, this feels more like a generic thriller than a Saw film. The kills and traps are disappointing, the big twist is weak, and the film doesn't know where it wants to go. An attempt to reinvent Saw that didn't succeed on any front.
Missing an item in this list?
Log in or create a free account to add an item yourself.
Log in / create account
This low-budget masterpiece by James Wan and Leigh Whannell is pure tension from start to finish.